One way to look at something powerful, iconic, or meaningful is with reverence: This place matters; this role matters; this institution stands for something bigger than me.
Another way to look at the same thing is with skepticism, even cynicism: This place is flawed; this role has been abused; this institution has caused harm as well as good.
Most people choose one of these views and cling to it, but the Stoics refused to; they believed wisdom requires both eyes open.
The Danger of Seeing With Only One Eye
When we see only the ideal, we can drift toward blind devotion. We might start to excuse bad behavior because the cause feels noble; we might start to bend the truth because “the mission is bigger than us.” We justify compromises because we do not want to tarnish something we admire.
And history is full of people who did wrong things while believing they were protecting something good.
But on the other hand, when we see only the flaws, we slide into corrosive cynicism.
Nothing matters, everyone is corrupt, every institution is a joke;cynicism can feel intelligent, but unchecked, it becomes lazy; it absolves us from responsibility. If everything is broken, why bother being honorable inside it?
But both extremes distort reality, and distorted reality leads to distorted behavior.
Reverence Has a Purpose
The Stoics understood the power of reverence. Seeing the higher meaning of a role, a place, or a responsibility can call us upward. It can remind us that we are part of something larger than our own comfort or ambition.
When we treat something as meaningful, we are more likely to rise to its demands: This is a special trust. I should act accordingly. I must do this justice.
That mindset can bring out discipline, restraint, and moral seriousness, especially when temptation or pressure appears, because reverence, used well, sharpens character.
Cynicism Has a Purpose Too
But reverence alone is not wisdom. The Stoics were deeply wary of illusion, especially the kind that grows around power, status, and symbols. Cynicism, when used properly, strips away mythology; it reminds us that institutions are run by fallible humans; that titles do not equal virtue, and that tradition does not guarantee truth.
And this clarity very very much matters. A person who sees clearly is harder to manipulate; harder to pressure, and harder to scare into obedience.
Used correctly cynicism says: No position excuses dishonesty! No title outranks integrity! No institution is worth sacrificing your soul for!
Again used correctly cynicism does not destroy meaning; it protects it.
The Balance That Creates Integrity
The Stoic goal was never to choose reverence or skepticism, but to hold both without being owned by either, to:
See the ideal and the reality! Respect the legacy and acknowledge the damage! Honor the role without worshipping the person in it!
A person who looks with both eyes is less likely to lie “for the greater good.” Less likely to excuse unethical behavior, and more likely to act with courage when it costs them.
They can say: “This matters too much to corrupt.” and “This is important enough to tell the truth about it.” That is moral strength.
This way of seeing is not just for politics or power; it applies everywhere life tempts us toward blindness.
How do you see marriage? As a sacred ideal or as a flawed human arrangement?
How do you see money? As security and opportunity or as a corrupting force?
How do you see success, recognition, and fame? As proof of worth or as something deeply imperfect and often undeserved?
The Stoic answer is always the same: both. See what something can be and what it actually is. See its promise and its history. See its beauty and its shadow.
Read Also: Conscientious Objection: When Obedience Conflicts With Conscience
Read Also: The Call to Engage: Why Good People Can’t Abandon a Broken System
Read Also: Speak Life: Never Let Encouragement Go Unspoken
Conclusion
Wisdom does not live at the extremes; it lives in clear vision: Look with both eyes! Be inspired without being deceived! Be skeptical without becoming bitter!
Hold the ideal in one hand! Hold reality in the other! And let neither one lie to you!
